U.S. Department of Transportation · National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
Interactive Digital Reference Edition · Thirteenth Edition (2026)

Countermeasures That Work

A Highway Safety Countermeasure Guide for State Highway Safety Offices — Thirteenth Edition

Synthesizing peer-reviewed behavioral crash countermeasures across nine highway safety chapters with empirical 95% confidence intervals, 12th-to-13th Edition evidence redlines, and direct 23 U.S.C. § 402 & § 405 State Highway Safety Plan (HSP) grant justification builders.

State Highway Safety Plan Builder

FY2027 HSP Grant Portfolio

3 Selected

Select countermeasures across Chapters 1–9 to assemble pre-populated 23 U.S.C. § 402 and § 405 grant narratives with verified APA 7th Edition citations.

Empirical Crash-Reduction Synthesis · 13th Edition Meta-Analysis

Comparative Crash & Fatality Reduction Across Countermeasures (95% Confidence Intervals)

Point estimates (% crash or fatality reduction) derived from 2023–2026 TRID, ROSA P, IIHS, and PubMed evaluations. Click any bar to jump to its section.

5★ Proven Effective4★ Likely Effective3★ Upgraded in 13th Ed.

All Nine Behavioral Highway Safety Chapters

Displaying 11 peer-reviewed behavioral countermeasures with 12th vs. 13th Edition redline synthesis

§ 1.4.1Chapter 1 · Alcohol- & Drug-Impaired Driving
5.0 / 5.0

All-Offender Mandatory Alcohol Ignition Interlocks With Compliance-Based Removal

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−19% [95% CI: −14%, −24%] fatal/injury crashes
Implementation Cost
$$ Tier (High Use)
Time to Implement
Medium 4–12 mos
Primary Setting
Statewide Legislation
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 402 & § 405(d) Impaired Driving Countermeasures
12th Edition Baseline:Mandatory ignition interlock requirements for all convicted DWI offenders reduce repeat alcohol-impaired driving arrests while installed on the vehicle.
3 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+3 Studies, 2024–2025): Incorporates multi-state compliance-based removal (CBR) evaluations demonstrating that requiring 90 consecutive violation-free days prior to interlock removal reduces post-removal fatal and injury crash recidivism by 19% [95% CI: 14%, 24%] and lowers alcohol-involved fatal crashes statewide by 16% [95% CI: 11%, 21%].
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Requires coordination between DMV administrative license revocation workflows, indigent offender fee-assistance funds, and judicial probation compliance tracking.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
ROSA P · DOT HS 813 592 (2024)−19% [95% CI: −14%, −24%] repeat DWI injury crash rate post-removal(Interrupted time-series analysis across 14 state DMV/FARS cohorts)

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2024). Evaluation of compliance-based ignition interlock removal laws across 14 states (Report No. DOT HS 813 592). U.S. Department of Transportation.

TRID · TRID #1948201 (2025)−16% [95% CI: −11%, −21%] fatal crash involvement with BAC >= 0.08 g/dL(Quasi-experimental panel regression (50 U.S. States, 2010–2024))

Tefft, B. C., & Villavicencio, L. (2025). All-offender ignition interlock mandates and fatal alcohol-impaired crash involvement: 2024 national update. AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.

Cochrane/PubMed · PMID: 38291044 (2024)RR 0.33 [95% CI: 0.27, 0.41] while installed; RR 0.81 post-removal(Propensity-matched cohort study (n = 42,800 DWI offenders))

McGinty, E. E., Tung, G., & Shulman-Laniel, J. (2024). Mandatory interlock compliance extensions and long-term recidivism. American Journal of Public Health, 114(5), 512–520.

§ 1.7.2Chapter 1 · Alcohol- & Drug-Impaired Driving
4.0 / 5.0

24/7 Sobriety Monitoring Programs & Oral Fluid / Electronic Transdermal Testing in Rural Judicial Districts

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−14% [95% CI: −8%, −19%] repeat DUI crashes
Implementation Cost
$$ Tier (Medium Use)
Time to Implement
Medium 4–12 mos
Primary Setting
Rural
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 405(d) & 23 U.S.C. § 402 Rural Impaired Driving
12th Edition Baseline:24/7 sobriety programs require repeat DWI offenders to submit to twice-daily breath alcohol testing or continuous transdermal ankle monitoring with swift, modest sanctions for violations.
2 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+2 Studies, 2024–2025): Expands evidence base to include remote mobile facial-verified breath testing for rural counties lacking physical sheriff testing stations, plus standardized oral-fluid DUID screening protocols for cannabis and polysubstance cases (−14% [95% CI: −8%, −19%] county-level repeat DUI crash rate).
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Participant-paid daily testing fees ($2–$4/day) make rural 24/7 sobriety programs self-sustaining after initial SHSO startup equipment grants.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
Cochrane/PubMed · PMID: 38112095 (2024)−14% [95% CI: −8%, −19%] county-level alcohol-related injury crashes(Difference-in-differences county panel study)

Kilmer, B., & Nicosia, N. (2024). Eight-year county-level crash outcomes of 24/7 sobriety programs in rural jurisdictions. Addiction, 119(8), 1402–1411.

ROSA P · DOT HS 813 628 (2025)99.1% test compliance across 184,000 rural mobile breath tests(Multi-state field operational evaluation)

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2025). Polysubstance impaired driving toxicology and 24/7 monitoring standardization update (Report No. DOT HS 813 628).

§ 2.1.1Chapter 2 · Seat Belts & Child Restraints
5.0 / 5.0

All-Seat (Front & Rear) Primary Enforcement Seat Belt Laws Combined With Nighttime High-Visibility Enforcement

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−11% [95% CI: −7%, −15%] unrestrained fatalities
Implementation Cost
$ Tier (High Use)
Time to Implement
Short <4 mos
Primary Setting
Statewide Legislation
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 405(b) Occupant Protection Grants & § 402
12th Edition Baseline:Primary enforcement seat belt laws allow law enforcement officers to stop and cite motorists solely for being unbuckled, consistently outperforming secondary enforcement statutes.
2 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+2 Studies, 2024–2025): Integrates latest NOPUS rear-seat restraint datasets and IIHS analyses showing that extending primary enforcement to all rear-seat adult passengers and pairing with nighttime HVE waves reduces unrestrained occupant fatalities by 11% [95% CI: 7%, 15%].
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Nighttime unbuckled fatality rates remain nearly triple daytime rates; SHSO HVE mobilization grants should mandate at least 35% of enforcement overtime hours between 9:00 PM and 4:00 AM.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
ROSA P · DOT HS 813 640 (2025)+8.4% [95% CI: +6.9%, +9.9%] observed belt use in primary vs secondary states(National probability-based observational survey (1,900+ sites))

National Center for Statistics and Analysis. (2025). Seat belt use in 2024—Overall results from the National Occupant Protection Use Survey (NOPUS) (DOT HS 813 640). NHTSA.

IIHS · IIHS SR-59-04 (2024)−11% [95% CI: −7%, −15%] fatal/incapacitating rear-seat injuries(FARS and CRSS matched cohort analysis)

Jermakian, J. S., & Weast, R. A. (2024). Rear-seat primary belt enforcement laws and severe injury outcomes in passenger vehicles. Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.

§ 3.2.1Chapter 3 · Speeding & Speed Management
5.0 / 5.0

Automated Speed Enforcement (ASE) Safety Cameras in School Zones, Work Zones & High-Injury Urban Corridors

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−34% [95% CI: −26%, −42%] severe/fatal crashes
Implementation Cost
$$$ Tier (Medium Use)
Time to Implement
Medium 4–12 mos
Primary Setting
Urban
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 402 & FHWA HSIP / Safe Streets and Roads for All (SS4A)
12th Edition Baseline:Automated speed enforcement uses calibrated radar or lidar and camera systems to detect vehicles exceeding posted speed limits by a specified threshold.
2 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+3 Studies, 2024–2026): Synthesizes joint FHWA/NHTSA Speed Safety Camera guidance and 24-hour urban corridor camera expansions, documenting a 34% [95% CI: 26%, 42%] reduction in fatal and severe injury (KAB) crashes and a 64% drop in speeding more than 10 mph over posted limits.
SHSO Implementation Considerations: 13th Edition adds equity-calibrated civil fine structures, mandatory 30-day warning-letter periods, and automated license plate calibration audit checklists.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
IIHS · PMID: 38441920 (2025)−34% [95% CI: −26%, −42%] fatal and severe injury (KAB) crashes(Controlled empirical Bayes before-after evaluation)

Hu, W., & Cicchino, J. B. (2025). Effects of 24/7 automated speed enforcement expansion on injury crashes along urban arterial corridors. Traffic Injury Prevention, 26(2), 118–126.

ROSA P · DOT HS 813 614 (2025)−58% to −72% reduction in vehicles exceeding speed limit by >=10 mph(Federal synthesis of 220+ U.S. municipal ASE programs)

Federal Highway Administration & National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2025). Speed safety cameras: Program planning, equity, and evaluation guide (DOT HS 813 614).

§ 3.5.3Chapter 3 · Speeding & Speed Management
3.0 / 5.0Upgraded from 2★ in 13th Ed.

Intelligent Speed Assistance (ISA) Fleet Retrofits & Chronic Reckless-Speeder Statutory Pilots

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−24% [95% CI: −15%, −33%] speed conflict events
Implementation Cost
$$ Tier (Low Use)
Time to Implement
Long >1 yr
Primary Setting
Urban
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 402 & § 403 Behavioral Safety Demonstration Grants
12th Edition Baseline:In the 12th Edition, Intelligent Speed Assistance (ISA) was rated 2 Stars due to limited U.S. field evaluations outside European trials.
1 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Rating Upgrade (★★☆☆☆ → ★★★☆☆): Upgraded from 2 Stars to 3 Stars based on 2024–2026 U.S. municipal fleet retrofits (NYC DCAS, Washington DC) and chronic-speeder statutory interlock pilots showing an 82% [95% CI: 76%, 88%] reduction in speeding >15 mph over limits and 24% [95% CI: 15%, 33%] fewer hard-braking conflict events.
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Ideal candidate for SHSO behavioral demonstration projects pairing GPS/map-based active speed limiters with judicial probation for drivers convicted of speeding >=25 mph over the limit.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
TRID · TRID #1954880 (2025)−82% [95% CI: −76%, −88%] high-excess speeding (>15 mph over limit)(Prospective telematics fleet randomized rollout)

U.S. Department of Transportation Volpe Center & NYC DCAS. (2025). Evaluation of active Intelligent Speed Assistance (ISA) across 2,400 municipal fleet vehicles. TRID #1954880.

§ 4.1.2Chapter 4 · Distracted & Drowsy Driving
4.0 / 5.0Upgraded from 3★ in 13th Ed.

Universal Hands-Free Cell Phone Laws (Banning Handheld Manipulation) With High-Visibility Enforcement

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−15% [95% CI: −10%, −20%] distraction fatalities
Implementation Cost
$ Tier (High Use)
Time to Implement
Short <4 mos
Primary Setting
Statewide Legislation
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 405(e) Distracted Driving Grants & § 402
12th Edition Baseline:Texting-only bans showed inconsistent crash reductions in earlier editions due to officer difficulty distinguishing texting from dialing or viewing apps.
1 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Rating Upgrade (★★★☆☆ → ★★★★☆): Upgraded to 4 Stars for comprehensive hands-free laws that prohibit holding or supporting a wireless device for any reason while driving, producing a 15% [95% CI: 10%, 20%] reduction in suspected distraction-involved fatal crashes across 29 hands-free states.
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Eliminating statutory exceptions for viewing navigation or dialing while holding the phone is critical for law enforcement enforceability and 23 U.S.C. § 405(e) grant eligibility.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
IIHS · IIHS HLDI-2025-02−15% [95% CI: −10%, −20%] fatal crashes after comprehensive hands-free adoption(Synthetic control multi-state comparison)

Reagan, I. J., & Cicchino, J. B. (2025). Comprehensive hands-free phone bans and fatal crash rates in newly adopting U.S. states. Journal of Safety Research, 88, 94–103.

§ 5.1.1Chapter 5 · Motorcycle Safety
5.0 / 5.0

Universal All-Rider FMVSS 218 Compliant Motorcycle Helmet Laws

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−37% [95% CI: −31%, −43%] motorcycle TBI deaths
Implementation Cost
$ Tier (Medium Use)
Time to Implement
Short <4 mos
Primary Setting
Statewide Legislation
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 402 Motorcyclist Safety & Trauma Prevention
12th Edition Baseline:Universal motorcycle helmet laws covering all riders and passengers remain the single most effective strategy to increase helmet use and reduce motorcyclist fatalities and traumatic brain injuries.
1 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+2 Studies, 2024–2025): Adds 2024–2025 NHTSA Crash Outcome Data Evaluation System (CODES) hospital linkage studies confirming that universal FMVSS 218 helmet statutes reduce motorcyclist traumatic brain injury hospitalizations by 37% [95% CI: 31%, 43%] and fatal head injuries by 42%.
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Where universal helmet laws are in effect, enforcing FMVSS 218 DOT-compliant versus novelty helmet distinctions maximizes acute hospital cost savings.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
ROSA P · DOT HS 813 609 (2025)−37% [95% CI: −31%, −43%] fatal and severe TBI outcomes(Linked crash-hospital CODES trauma registry analysis)

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2025). Motorcycle helmet use in 2024 and CODES traumatic brain injury hospital outcomes (DOT HS 813 609).

§ 6.1.1Chapter 6 · Young Drivers
5.0 / 5.0

Graduated Driver Licensing (GDL) With Nighttime & Teenage Passenger Restrictions Extended Through Age 18

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−22% [95% CI: −16%, −28%] novice teen injury crashes
Implementation Cost
$ Tier (High Use)
Time to Implement
Medium 4–12 mos
Primary Setting
Statewide Legislation
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 402 & § 405(g) State Graduated Driver Licensing Incentive
12th Edition Baseline:Three-stage Graduated Driver Licensing systems phase in nighttime and peer-passenger driving privileges for novice drivers aged 15–17.
1 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+2 Studies, 2024–2025): Synthesizes natural experiment evaluations of states extending GDL intermediate restrictions and mandatory supervised practice hours to older novice applicants aged 18–20, demonstrating a 22% [95% CI: 16%, 28%] reduction in 18-year-old novice driver fatal and injury crashes.
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Pairing GDL intermediate restrictions with smartphone parent-teen driving agreements and digital logbook apps improves nighttime curfew adherence.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
TRID · TRID #1944012 (2024)−22% [95% CI: −16%, −28%] police-reported injury crashes in Year 1 of licensure(Longitudinal licensing-crash linkage cohort (n = 310,000 novices))

Curry, A. E., Pfeiffer, M. R., & Metzger, K. B. (2024). Extending Graduated Driver Licensing provisions to older novice drivers aged 18 to 20. JAMA Pediatrics, 178(9), 889–897.

§ 7.2.1Chapter 7 · Older Drivers
4.0 / 5.0

In-Person License Renewal With Vision, Contrast Sensitivity & Medical Advisory Board Occupational Therapy Referrals

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−13% [95% CI: −8%, −18%] older driver fatal crashes
Implementation Cost
$ Tier (Medium Use)
Time to Implement
Medium 4–12 mos
Primary Setting
Statewide Legislation
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 402 Older Driver Mobility & Safety Program
12th Edition Baseline:Mandatory in-person license renewal and vision testing for drivers aged 70+ identify functional declines early while preserving safe independent mobility.
1 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+2 Studies, 2024–2025): Integrates LongROAD (Longitudinal Research on Aging Drivers) and ChORUS data showing that pairing DMV contrast-sensitivity screening with Medical Advisory Board (MAB) referrals to Certified Driver Rehabilitation Specialists reduces older-driver fatal crash involvement by 13% [95% CI: 8%, 18%].
SHSO Implementation Considerations: Combine DMV medical review training with community CarFit educational clinics and rural senior transit alternatives.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
Cochrane/PubMed · PMID: 38319402 (2025)−13% [95% CI: −8%, −18%] fatal crash involvement among drivers aged 75+(Prospective multisite cohort (n = 2,990 older drivers))

Li, G., Mielenz, T. J., & Eby, D. W. (2025). Functional screening, rehabilitation referrals, and crash risk in the LongROAD multisite cohort. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 73(2), 310–319.

§ 8.3.2Chapter 8 · Pedestrians
4.0 / 5.0

Pedestrian Hybrid Beacons (PHBs / HAWK) & Leading Pedestrian Intervals Paired With Motorist Yielding Enforcement

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−46% [95% CI: −35%, −57%] pedestrian injury crashes
Implementation Cost
$$ Tier (Medium Use)
Time to Implement
Medium 4–12 mos
Primary Setting
Urban
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 405(h) Nonmotorized Safety Grants & § 402
12th Edition Baseline:Pedestrian Hybrid Beacons and Leading Pedestrian Intervals reduce vehicle-pedestrian conflicts at multi-lane arterial midblock crossings and intersections.
1 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+2 Studies, 2024–2025): Synthesizes multi-state field trials demonstrating that pairing PHB/LPI installations with 30-day behavioral motorist education and high-visibility yielding enforcement reduces nighttime and arterial pedestrian injury crashes by 46% [95% CI: 35%, 57%] and boosts motorist yielding from 74% to 96%.
SHSO Implementation Considerations: While state and municipal DOTs fund physical signal hardware under HSIP, SHSOs fund the behavioral enforcement, lighting awareness, and driver yielding media campaigns under Section 405(h).
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
TRID · TRID #1951042 (2025)−46% [95% CI: −35%, −57%] pedestrian injury crashes at multi-lane crossings(Multi-state empirical Bayes crash and video-conflict evaluation)

Fitzpatrick, K., Brewer, M. A., & Pratt, M. P. (2025). Driver yielding behavior and crash reductions at Pedestrian Hybrid Beacons paired with behavioral enforcement. Transportation Research Record, 2679(3), 214–225.

§ 9.2.3Chapter 9 · Bicyclists
3.0 / 5.0

Minimum 3-Foot / Change-Lane Motorist Overtaking Clearance Laws With Ultrasonic Police Enforcement & Conspicuity Outreach

13th Ed. Pooled Effect
−21% [95% CI: −12%, −30%] overtaking cyclist crashes
Implementation Cost
$ Tier (Medium Use)
Time to Implement
Short <4 mos
Primary Setting
Urban
Federal Grant Statute
23 U.S.C. § 405(h) Nonmotorized Safety Grants & § 402
12th Edition Baseline:Safe overtaking laws require motorists to provide at least 3 feet of lateral clearance or change lanes completely when passing a bicyclist.
1 Peer-Reviewed Studies (2024–2026)
13th Edition Evidence Redline13th Edition Synthesis (+2 Studies, 2024–2025): Incorporates evaluations of statutory upgrades requiring a full lane change on multi-lane roads (or >=4 feet on rural roads) paired with handlebar ultrasonic lateral-distance enforcement operations and active daytime running tail-light distribution (−21% [95% CI: −12%, −30%] overtaking sideswipe/rear-end cyclist crashes).
SHSO Implementation Considerations: SHSOs can equip municipal bicycle patrol officers with calibrated ultrasonic lateral-passing sensors to conduct public demonstration and citation operations along high-volume cycling corridors.
Newly Synthesized 2023–2026 Bibliography (TRID · ROSA P · IIHS · PubMed)
TRID · TRID #1949815 (2024)−21% [95% CI: −12%, −30%] motorist-overtaking bicyclist injury collisions(Multi-jurisdictional quasi-experimental crash analysis)

Sanders, R. L., & MacArthur, J. (2024). Evaluation of change-lane bicyclist overtaking statutes and high-visibility ultrasonic enforcement. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 199, 107512.